Why Can't the Pirates Win 85 Games? A Mailbag Analysis
Joe Starkey tackles fan questions about the Pittsburgh Pirates' potential, from the odds of winning 85 games to the likelihood of a World Series parade. He also discusses the Steelers' receiver situation, the Pirates' payroll spending, and the future of star pitcher Paul Skenes.
The Challenge of 85 Wins
Frank from Cranberry wonders if the Pirates can reach 85 wins, given their current roster and the odds set by Vegas. Starkey acknowledges the challenge, noting that most projections place them around 77-78 wins. However, he believes the team has the potential to improve with key players like Konnor Griffin and Paul Skenes.
The Power of Star Players
Starkey highlights the importance of generational talent in sports. He compares Griffin to Willie Mays and Mike Trout, suggesting that the Pirates may have landed two such players. He emphasizes the need for young starters and internal improvement from players like Bryan Reynolds and Oneil Cruz to reach the 85-win mark.
The Steelers' Receiver Dilemma
J, @Crosslands895, asks about the Steelers' receiver situation. Starkey acknowledges the team's need for more receivers and mentions his previous article on the topic. He suggests that the Steelers might address this issue in the upcoming free agency period.
Pirates' Payroll and Spending Spree
Ed Helinski inquires about the Pirates' payroll spending and whether it's a genuine effort to win. Starkey clarifies that the Pirates are finally showing a willingness to compete, but he doesn't see them splurging on high-priced free agents. The team's payroll has surpassed $100 million, which Starkey considers a necessary step towards competitiveness.
The Future of Paul Skenes
Roman Wozniak III questions whether the Pirates' spending is enough to keep star pitcher Paul Skenes. Starkey believes Skenes is more likely to be traded before his free agency date, as the team has control over his rights for only a few more seasons.
